Going to try to walk in tomorrow night, even though they're fully booked up on Rezy two weeks out now (prior to the Times re-review, they were wide open). Best backup options in the area if it doesn't work out? Scarr's?
Scarr's or Williamsburg Pizza for NY-style (Scarr's has a wine list and better atmosphere imo), there's also a Speedy Romeo nearby.
For traditional Neapolitan pizza, apparently Sorbillo has improved since opening...
I never knew a pizza could soak as much olive oil as the grandma pie at Williamsburg Pizza, delicious of course.