Jump to content
Wilfrid1

Union Square Cafe

Recommended Posts

Revealing that we have no thread on the place. I suspect that if any members use it, they've nothing new to say about it. I hadn't been for years, but noticed ready availability on Open Table recently, so decided to remind myself what it was like.

 

It's showing some wear around the edges, but all desire to comment in detail was swept aside by some very poor food. This is a good opportunity for everyone to explain to me both how I should have ordered differently, and how I should better have handled the situation when I didn't like what I got.

 

I am all ears.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haven't you heard? Joe Dobias is now working there as a consultant. He'll do for them what he did for his other restaurant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought of you when I wrote it up, because I don't know what damn greens were in the dish, and it really didn't matter. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

looks like we dodged a bullet yesterday, then. when we had to change our meeting time we looked on opentable to see if there was space for 5 at 1pm. when we saw that there was space for 5 at every half hour interval, we thought it very odd and went back to our original plan. haven't eaten at USC for a few years but had never been disappointed in the past. i think i'll play it safe and just hang onto those good memories.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
looks like we dodged a bullet yesterday, then. when we had to change our meeting time we looked on opentable to see if there was space for 5 at 1pm. when we saw that there was space for 5 at every half hour interval, we thought it very odd and went back to our original plan. haven't eaten at USC for a few years but had never been disappointed in the past. i think i'll play it safe and just hang onto those good memories.

I hear the duck confit is memorable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the first - and last - time i ate there must have been about 10 years ago and it was nothing to write home about either, food-wise. the service and wine were highlights.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had the exact same dish as you last month when USQ was chosen as a non-threatening venue for us to take my fiancees younger siblings (18 and 21) for one of their first "fine dining experiences." I pushed for Craft, but it wasn't my call and I wasn't paying.

 

It was a pretty uninteresting meal. All around, but the menu had plenty of things on it that weren't going to scare anyone.

 

It was a terrifyingly large portion that was pretty lame. Although my greens weren't overly bitter - in fact I thought they were Spinach at the time. But the mostarda was pointless, and the duck was not good. It didn't even have a confit texture.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
terrifyingly large portion

 

It didn't even that confit texture.

 

Right and right.

 

I suspect that there are better dishes on the menu than that duck, not that it is excusable.

 

I thought about that too. Unless I am overlooking specials, meat choices are limited to chicken, steak, duck and lamb chops "scotta dita." Given the restaurant's Italian slant, the chops might be a better choice; given that I don't tend to order roast chicken when eating out, and reserve steaks for places that specialize in them, the duck loomed as inevitable. (Yes, there's fish and pasta, of course.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Several of us went last December and I remember the meal as thoroughly mediocre. Not enough so that I would pan it, but definitely enough to not wish to return any time soon. My only real memory of anything enjoyable was the bread basket. Well.. the wine too, but I'm pretty sure that we paid corkage and that someone brought it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Revealing that we have no thread on the place. I suspect that if any members use it, they've nothing new to say about it. I hadn't been for years, but noticed ready availability on Open Table recently, so decided to remind myself what it was like.

 

It's showing some wear around the edges, but all desire to comment in detail was swept aside by some very poor food. This is a good opportunity for everyone to explain to me both how I should have ordered differently, and how I should better have handled the situation when I didn't like what I got.

 

I am all ears.

 

I've thought about this some more - the sizable red herring in the anti-blogger stance by chefs (as opposed to the legitimate one by, say, LML) is that the lack of education among reviewers causes responses on blogs and review sites to be overwhelmingly positive.

 

On Yelp, JoeDoe, Ssam Bar, Union Square Cafe, 2nd Ave Deli, Sparks, Prune, Ippudo... all have the same score (4 stars)

 

You should have thrown the dish on the floor and said you thought it was a rat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I've thought about this some more - the sizable red herring in the anti-blogger stance by chefs (as opposed to the legitimate one by, say, LML) is that the lack of education among reviewers causes responses on blogs and review sites to be overwhelmingly positive.

 

On Yelp, JoeDoe, Ssam Bar, Union Square Cafe, 2nd Ave Deli, Sparks, Prune, Ippudo... all have the same score (4 stars)

Yes, and funnily enough chefs complain only about the bad reviews. If someone says that Union Square Café is better than Le Bernardin, Danny Meyer isn't going to correct them, even though he realizes this isn't the case.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Revealing that we have no thread on the place. I suspect that if any members use it, they've nothing new to say about it. I hadn't been for years, but noticed ready availability on Open Table recently, so decided to remind myself what it was like.

 

It's showing some wear around the edges, but all desire to comment in detail was swept aside by some very poor food. This is a good opportunity for everyone to explain to me both how I should have ordered differently, and how I should better have handled the situation when I didn't like what I got.

 

I am all ears.

 

I've thought about this some more - the sizable red herring in the anti-blogger stance by chefs (as opposed to the legitimate one by, say, LML) is that the lack of education among reviewers causes responses on blogs and review sites to be overwhelmingly positive.

 

On Yelp, JoeDoe, Ssam Bar, Union Square Cafe, 2nd Ave Deli, Sparks, Prune, Ippudo... all have the same score (4 stars)

 

You should have thrown the dish on the floor and said you thought it was a rat.

Having spent money people are loathe to admit they got ripped off. It is human nature.

 

 

My favorite example of the issue Orik is talking about (I know there is some smart sounding statistical name for it?) is the Long Island Zagat guide. There its a geographic issue. Clientele in Great Neck seem to always be pissed off about something. Massapequa people seem to love everything. Makes the book useless even compared to other Zagats.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Having spent money people are loathe to admit they got ripped off. It is human nature.

That is certainly true, though it doesn't fully explain the problem. A rating of four stars for Union Square Café is only meaningful if you know where else the person has dined. If their regular meal out is Olive Garden, then USC would be a pretty big step up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
looks like we dodged a bullet yesterday, then. when we had to change our meeting time we looked on opentable to see if there was space for 5 at 1pm. when we saw that there was space for 5 at every half hour interval, we thought it very odd and went back to our original plan. haven't eaten at USC for a few years but had never been disappointed in the past. i think i'll play it safe and just hang onto those good memories.

I hear the duck confit is memorable.

my g-d, man! we had an infant with us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...